
Stonefather ~Orson Scott Card
–published in this version 2008
–112 pages, Subterranean Press
–4/5 stars
A light snow was falling, a long four-day weekend was coming to a close, the seasonal sounds of televised football were buzzing in the background and I felt the need to pull something off the shelf that I could complete in one sitting–something that would mimic the warm glow I was already feeling after a very restful holiday. Stonefather, one of my latest acquisitions from that smoldering temptress Subterranean Press, looked like it would fit my requirements nicely. A few hours later, in the waning light of day, I closed this novella with a contented sigh and the remembrance of just why I enjoy the way that Orson Scott Card tells a story.
This novella-length story was previously featured in the Wizards anthology and was re-released in this special edition by Subterranean Press to act as a prequel of sorts to Orson Scott Cards forthcoming Mithermages series. Though I am not generally a fan of long, drawn out series, this novella whetted the appetite in such a way that I will be tempted to join in as Card releases these volumes.
Stonefather tells the tale of a young man, Runnel, who grows tired of his father’s beatings and his siblings’ animosity and decides to leave his small farm-based community to travel to the city of Mitherhome, the legendary city of the water mages. Stonefather follows the path of a typical coming-of-age story in that our hero acquires a greater knowledge of himself and his own worth through the trials and tribulations of his journey. Where Stonefather stands out is in Card’s skill with characterization. Almost immediately I developed a liking for Runnel and it is a feeling that carried throughout the story. In this very slim volume Card manages to capture the essence of this young man in a way that makes you want to follow him on his journeys. Along the way Runnel meets a small cast of characters most of which were also very enjoyable to encounter. A story like this, one that does not have the good fortune of having hundreds of pages to be told, can very easily suffer because of its brevity and although I had a few minor quibbles it is a testament to the craftsmanship of Orson Scott Card that he was able to present a character, and a world, with such meat to it in so few pages.
If I were to judge this novel with a more critical eye I would probably give it a 3.5 out of 5 stars. As the book came to a close I felt that Card changed from a more leisurely but engaging pace to a very rushed pace as he tried to bring closer to some of the relationships that sprang up during Runnel’s journey. While I completely understand the need to do so, particularly as this story was included in a previous anthology, I wish Card would have taken the time to flesh the ending out a bit more. This was a minor quibble, however, because of the liking I had taken to the character by this point. I rated the book 4 out of 5 stars because of my experience with it. I quickly became lost in the world Card created–a world of strong nature magic with a character who loved rocks and mountains and stone. It was a fascinating and comforting world that Card created and Runnel has a bit of the everyman to him that makes him easy to relate with. I was able to shut out the world around me and experience the glimmer of magic in Card’s story and the satisfaction I felt after being told a good story on a Sunday afternoon cannot be overstated. This was a very enjoyable way to close out my reading for the month of November.
This particular volume has a gorgeous cover illustration and interior illustrations by Tom Kidd. His rendering of the world, albeit only a brief glimpse, is very fitting with the world Card paints with his words. This volume appears to be available through Amazon though it is sold out at the Subterranean site. And this story can also be found in the Wizards anthology. I highly recommend this read and look forward to being tempted by Card’s upcoming series.
I read this as one of the stories in Wizards, and it was one of the few stories I really enjoyed! The painting on this cover is gorgeous! but it’s too pricey for me for such a short story and one I’ve read already… but everytime I see this cover I have to stop and look at it! sheesh!
…duh. didn’t mean to hit send yet lol
I will read the first book when it finally comes out!
What a nice cover! I really need to read more from Card…
We need to touch base and figure out a plan for the Advent Calendar. Don’t forget about me!
I quickly became lost in the world Card createdβa world of strong nature magic with a character who loved rocks and mountains and stone.
It’s good to know that 1) Card has a new book out, and 2)It’s a good one (and not Ender-related!). Thanks for the review.
I’ll definitely be in line to get Mithermages Book 1 when it comes out! Glad you enjoyed it Carl. It really was a fantastic story and I’m so excited about this series. I think in general, I like Card’s fantasy even better than his sci-fi. By the way, I do agree with you that the ending felt a bit rushed in the way things were wrapped up. I would’ve liked to seen the ending fleshed out some more, but the novella was still a great one!
Deslily: Other than the first couple of stories I haven’t read any more of the Wizards anthology…yet. π
Kailana: I haven’t forgotten, I was actually thinking about this on the way to work this morning.
Melissa: If you like Card you will probably enjoy this…and of course Card does have a new Ender related book out now as well. π
Chris: Other than this I haven’t read anything to compare. As much as I love Ender’s Game and Speaker for the Dead I cannot imagine liking anything else he has written more, but I’m certainly open to it. And this was a really nice story despite the rushed ending. As I said, I just really, really liked Runnel.
The cover is worth the purchase alone in my opinion and is honestly 100% of the reason I picked this book up. I’m a sucker for covers too many times. Your review of an enjoyable tale as well just makes the purchase a bonus. π
If you want a good Card fantasy, you could go with Magic Street for an Urban Fantasy with some Shakespeare themes…or Enchantment which is an excellent fairy tale retelling.
You’re not alone there Jeff. Mine wasn’t quite a hundred percent but pretty close. I had a little bit of an interest because of liking Card’s writing, but I’m probably still up there in the way upper 90 percentile range on wanting it simply for Kidd’s cover. π
Thanks for the recommendations Chris.
Oh, yes, the cover! It looks like a world I’d want to retreat to for a while.
I only vaguely remember this one from his larger story collection. I’ll have to go back and check it out, because I definitely feel like I was missing something.
i have been tempted to get this a lot of time because of the beautiful cover! reading the review, i want it even more π maybe i should just get the Wizards anthology, which i had planned to get anyway, but to tell the truth i probably would purchase this edition as well – the cover is so worth it!